Orthography: Difference between revisions

From Nümü Yaduana
Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
No edit summary
 
Line 1: Line 1:
Written Paiute is not governed by an authoritative standards body, and as such, the orthography used by local communities and scholars to represent the language varies. I see these standards as falling into three major groups:
Written Paiute is not governed by an authoritative standards body, and as such, the orthography used by local communities and scholars to represent the language varies. I see these standards as falling into three major groups:


* '''Linguistic''' orthographies that sacrifice aesthetics in order to faithfully transcribe the sounds recorded in fieldwork. These are common in Paiute grammars produced as doctoral theses, and in the usages examples within entries in the ''Northern Paiute-Bannock Dictionary''.
* '''Linguistic''' orthographies that sacrifice aesthetics in order to faithfully transcribe the sounds recorded in fieldwork. These are common in Paiute grammars produced as doctoral theses, and in the usage examples within entries in the ''Northern Paiute-Bannock Dictionary''.
* '''Standard''' (for lack of a better term) orthography represents Paiute in a way that broadly aligns with the majority of languages using the Roman alphabet.
* '''Standard''' (for lack of a better term) orthography represents Paiute in a way that broadly aligns with the majority of languages using the Roman alphabet. ''Northern Paiute-Bannock Dictionary'' entry headings and the ''Northern Paiute Language Project'' "linguistic orthography" are examples of these.
* '''Wycliffe''' orthography is designed to be convenient for English speakers, using only [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ASCII ASCII] characters and vowel representations that match English orthography following the [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Vowel_Shift Great Vowel Shift].
* '''Wycliffe''' orthography is designed to be convenient for English speakers, using only [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ASCII ASCII] characters and vowel representations that match English orthography following the [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Vowel_Shift Great Vowel Shift].


Pyramid Lake uses the Wycliffe system, and the course material represented in this site is provided in Wycliffe. I find a "standard" orthography to be most convenient for my own reading and for referencing the dictionary, so I primarily use such a system on this site, supplementing with Wycliffe where able.
A "standard" orthography is most convenient for my own reading and reference (particularly looking up words in NP-B), so I use one across the site. This orthography is functionally equivalent to the one in NP-B while making some adjustments for aesthetics, clarity, and ease of use. I use NP-B entry headings as the authoritative source for spelling, and when multiple spellings are listed, I use the one that aligns with Pyramid Lake pronunciation received in class.


My "standard" orthography diverges slightly from some others for the sake of convenience and typographic aesthetics. This is most obvious in the representation of phonemes like ''kw'', ''ng'' and ''ts'' with a single glyph, as I find it helpful to represent each phoneme with a single glyph.
Pyramid Lake and the UNR course taught to its standard use Wycliffe. Material on this site from that course is provided with accompanying Wycliffe representations, as given.


{| class="wikitable sortable"
{| class="wikitable sortable"
Line 24: Line 24:
| ae
| ae
| [e]
| [e]
| Pyramid Lake features an [e] where other dialects have [ai], and its Wycliffe system reflects that with ''ae''. I use a circumflex as a mnemonic to remember to pronounce [e] without diverging from dictionary spelling.
| Pyramid Lake features an [e] where other dialects have [ai], and its Wycliffe system reflects that with '''ae'''. I use a circumflex as a mnemonic to remember to pronounce [e] while remaining faithful to dictionary spelling.
|-
|-
! b
! b
Line 57: Line 57:
| gw
| gw
| [gʷ], [ɣʷ]
| [gʷ], [ɣʷ]
|  
| See '''ķ'''.
|-
|-
! h
! h
Line 95: Line 95:
| kw
| kw
| [kʷ]
| [kʷ]
| This is an unusual choice, as all other Paiute orthographies use ''kw'', but I consider it a helpful reminder that this is a distinct phoneme and not a consonant cluster.
|-
|-
! m
! m
Line 162: Line 163:
| ts, tz
| ts, tz
| [ts]
| [ts]
| NP-B example transcriptions have ''c'' for [ts], but the entry heading orthography is ''ts''.
| NP-B usage examples have '''c''' for [ts], but the entry heading orthography is '''ts'''. I like '''c''' because it isn't used otherwise and keeps each phoneme corresponding to a single glyph.
|-
|-
! ç
! ç
Line 169: Line 170:
| dy
| dy
| [tʃ]
| [tʃ]
| Another unusual choice (NP-B usage examples and Thornes use '''č''' instead), but I like the cedilla for visual consistency with '''ķ'''.
|-
|-
! u
! u

Latest revision as of 22:23, 26 August 2025

Written Paiute is not governed by an authoritative standards body, and as such, the orthography used by local communities and scholars to represent the language varies. I see these standards as falling into three major groups:

  • Linguistic orthographies that sacrifice aesthetics in order to faithfully transcribe the sounds recorded in fieldwork. These are common in Paiute grammars produced as doctoral theses, and in the usage examples within entries in the Northern Paiute-Bannock Dictionary.
  • Standard (for lack of a better term) orthography represents Paiute in a way that broadly aligns with the majority of languages using the Roman alphabet. Northern Paiute-Bannock Dictionary entry headings and the Northern Paiute Language Project "linguistic orthography" are examples of these.
  • Wycliffe orthography is designed to be convenient for English speakers, using only ASCII characters and vowel representations that match English orthography following the Great Vowel Shift.

A "standard" orthography is most convenient for my own reading and reference (particularly looking up words in NP-B), so I use one across the site. This orthography is functionally equivalent to the one in NP-B while making some adjustments for aesthetics, clarity, and ease of use. I use NP-B entry headings as the authoritative source for spelling, and when multiple spellings are listed, I use the one that aligns with Pyramid Lake pronunciation received in class.

Pyramid Lake and the UNR course taught to its standard use Wycliffe. Material on this site from that course is provided with accompanying Wycliffe representations, as given.

This site NP-B NPLP Wycliffe IPA Notes
a a a a [a]
âi ai ai ae [e] Pyramid Lake features an [e] where other dialects have [ai], and its Wycliffe system reflects that with ae. I use a circumflex as a mnemonic to remember to pronounce [e] while remaining faithful to dictionary spelling.
b b b b [b], [β]
d d d d [d], [ɾ]
dz dz dz tz [dz] The difference between dz and z is a little murky, at least in Pyramid Lake dialect, which tends to represent both as tz in Wycliffe. I generally follow the NP-B spelling while pronouncing words as heard spoken.
g g g g [g], [ɣ]
ģ gw gw gw [gʷ], [ɣʷ] See ķ.
h h h h [h], [χ]
ʻ ʔ ' ' [ʔ] I use a "modifier letter turned comma" character like the Hawaiian ʻokina because the typography is aesthetically pleasing, and it avoids glottal stops being misidentified as word boundaries by software when working with text on a computer.
i i i e [i]
ii ii ii e, ee [i:]
k k k k [k], [x]
ķ kw kw kw [kʷ] This is an unusual choice, as all other Paiute orthographies use kw, but I consider it a helpful reminder that this is a distinct phoneme and not a consonant cluster.
m m m m [m]
mm mm mm mm [m:]
n n n n [n:]
ŋ ng ng ng [ŋ] Pronouncing ng as [ŋg] instead of [ŋ] is a common error for English speakers!
o o o o [ɔ], [o]
oo oo oo o [ɔ:], [o:]
p p p p [p]
s s s s [s], [ʃ] (following [i])
ss ss ss s [s:], [ʃ:]
t t t t [t]
c ts ts ts, tz [ts] NP-B usage examples have c for [ts], but the entry heading orthography is ts. I like c because it isn't used otherwise and keeps each phoneme corresponding to a single glyph.
ç ch dd dy [tʃ] Another unusual choice (NP-B usage examples and Thornes use č instead), but I like the cedilla for visual consistency with ķ.
u u u oo [u] In Wycliffe, [uʔu] (at least word-finally) is represented as oo'o.
uu u u oo [u:] Difficulty representing [u:] is a weakness of Wycliffe.
ü ɨ ü u [ɨ] I was tempted to use ı, but it would require retooling capital letters and may look odd or confuse people. NPLP "linguistic orthography" and some other sources use ü for this phoneme, so it is not without precedent.
üü ɨɨ üü u [ɨ:]
w w w w [w]
y y y y [j]
z z z tz [z] Tends to sound the same as dz or Wycliffe tz in Pyramid Lake dialect.